Published by Harlequin on October 1, 2018 This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review. I cannot wait to see what Ms.I received this book for free from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. I very much appreciate the opportunity and and am kicking myself for not having picked this up in October as I had originally planned. Thank you so much to the publisher, Graydon House Books, for providing me with a copy to read and review.

I would definitely recommend this book to anyone who loves historical fiction, especially if you enjoy things with a gothic atmosphere. I did take off a half a star just because there were moments where I felt the drama was repetitive and could have been shortened up a bit but that is very slight and 100% my opinion. All the drama, the overarching feeling of suspense, the subtle supernatural undertones, the hauntings, the domestic drama – soooo fun! Overall, I was very impressed with the book. Honestly, it’s a wonder anyone ended up with the person they wanted to be with! I just cannot even imagine dealing with all that formality. I am so exhausted by the courtship patterns of this time period.

It is not a warm and fuzzy sisterly relationship by any means and in fact, their constant battling provides most of the drama in the book. The interactions between the sisters, particularly Catherine and Lydia, reminded me so much of Downton Abbey with Mary and Edith. It is by no means the bulk of the story but hints of it are sprinkled throughout with it becoming a more prominent feature in the second half. In regards to witchcraft, it is subtle in nature, and I felt very well portrayed. There is always an underlining feeling of menace just under the surface. I loved the gothic vibes that extend throughout the story. I was surprised to learn this is a debut as the writing seems so experienced. The setting and language of this novel are absolutely beautiful. The three sisters – Catherine, Lydia & Emeline – take the move as well as can be expected and before too long are settling into their new life with only minor complaints. Forced to flee Boston in the wake of scandalous rumors, the Montrose Family, moves into their summer estate, Willow Hall, in New Oldbury, Massachusetts.

The witch of willow hall by hester fox